Goodfella's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant

My Fiancé and I decided to go and try this place out after not having been in a while. It was a disaster to say the least. To start, my fiancé asked for the Pasta Fagioli...and the soup came out brown, not red. If you've had this soup before, you know it isn't a brown colored soup. The table bread was flavorless. Then the entrees came. When we ordered, I explicitly asked for a Large Pizza Bianca with chicken and bacon. To my surprise, Goodfella's white sauce is actually a red sauce, and there was no ricotta on my pizza as there should be on a Pizza Bianca. I went ahead and ate the pizza as I was hungry, and it was essentially flavorless. I could only soldier through 2 slices. My Fiancé ordered the chicken parm, and that chicken parm and spaghetti was swimming in tomato soup at the bottom o

Food and service were outstanding from start to finish. The only downside was the wait, which was a little longer than we’d hoped for—but once the food hit the table, it was clear it was worth it. We ordered the Extra Cheese Calzone, and it was everything you want in comfort food. The crust was golden, with a slight crisp on the outside and soft, chewy layers inside. The cheese blend was rich and gooey, with that perfect balance of salty and creamy that stretches beautifully with each bite. Every mouthful had that indulgent, melty texture you only get when the cheese-to-crust ratio is spot-on. The Deluxe Stromboli was equally impressive. The crust had a light crunch that gave way to warm, savory fillings—pepperoni, sausage, peppers, onions, and mushrooms—each ingredient holding its own w

We had a Groupon and thought we would try it- its dog friendly so we sat outside. They were short staffed and heard the server tell another family sitting outside that service would be slower out there due to staffing. Antipasto salad was really good and so were the chicken strips- we had to sit outside because we brought our dogs and service was a little delayed. We decided we would give it another try and leave the fur babies at home. I would really like to try the pizza.

Was good! I ordered extra cheese on my meatball sub because normally places are a little skimpy, but this place came through! Bread was good, meatballs were tasty. Will definitely be back, and now I know I can trust them to deliver what I ask for. Oh, and the cheese was so good I was tearing off the extra from the wrapper and eating it straight 😂🤤

The first thing I see and hear when walking in the front door is a server loudly arguing with a cook. The girl that took my order and then brought it to me, was nice. I then ordered pizza to go. To say it is by far the worst pizza I've ever had is not enough. The vegetables were not diced, they were in big chunks. The edges were hard and burned yet the middle of the pie soggy and undercooked. The tomato sauce was just ok, nothing memorable. I'm not sure why this place has so many rave reviews, maybe the owner's mother is writing them. So it's back to NSB for good pizza.