Goodfellas Pizzeria - Gulch

The atmosphere here is top notch—really cool vibe and a great place to hang out. The service was equally impressive; the staff was friendly and efficient. We ordered a whole fresh pie and some buffalo cheese sticks. The buffalo cheese sticks were the star of the show—incredible flavor, served hot, with a perfect balance of meat, crust, and sauce. The cheese pizza was solid, though a bit floppy for my personal preference. I usually lean toward a much crunchier, thin-crust style, and while this was good, I’ve had better pies elsewhere in town. I’d definitely come back, especially if I’m in the area and convenience dictates. It's a great spot to grab a bite!

Great pizza, huge slices! As someone from New York, finding a solid slice outside of NY is hard, but Goodfellas definitely delivered. The lunch special was perfect: a generous slice, a side, and a drink at a great price. The décor fits the vibe perfectly, and we genuinely enjoyed our lunch. Can’t wait to come back for more!

Not only was the pizza incredibly delicious, the breadstick was amazingly seasoned for flavor too. From the sofas to the benches the vibe and feel was on point, and what all pizzerias should aspire to be. The service was also top notch and they all cared about the quality and speed of food getting into your belly. Looking forward to coming here again the next time we are in town.

Loved Goodfellas in other locations and this was just as good. Got a big pizza, calzone and huge breadstick which was all very tasty. Delicious food and the staff were friendly.

Stopped in to try a slice. Firstly, the slices are enormous. 1 is plenty for most people, so the $5.51 (with tax) pricetag is fair. The crust has an amazing crunch. They're using the correct Italian sausage. You'll understand what I mean when you taste it. I prefer a little more sauce on my pizza, but the amount will be acceptable for most people. Overall a solid pizza place that I'll be coming back to.