Goodfella's Pizzeria

Never had a bad meal here. Pizza or pasta - always good. Salads are simple and nice. Cookie massive. People nice. It’s the whole package!

Two out of the last three delivery orders have been less than satisfactory. Today 02/24/2026 was the worst. She answered with "hold' which I understand, but when I placed my order she told me we don't deliveries. Really?

I am very impressed! I have a delivery where order! The driver is always friendly! When I called my order in , extremely polite people! The food is excellent! 10 stars rating from me!

The manager gave me burnt wings. Many people after us received food before us, including wings that were NOT burnt. She said that is how they come out. She wasn’t just lying. She was gaslighting about the food and the slow service. If she wanted to run us off, she succeeded.

Absolutely hands down the best pizza place in Grove. There are chains nearby if you like having the same thing. But if you are looking for a good pie at a very reasonable price then look no further. We didn't try the dessert this time around but we will be looking forward to that in the future. Great customer service and excellent food. Easy place to find as well.