Goodfella's New York Italian Deli

The chicken cutlets are phenomenal! I highly recommend the food and the service was outstanding. They were obviously very busy when I picked up my food and yet they still offered to help me take it all to my car. Great place, great food and great people from what I experienced!

was back in town for the weekend looking for a good authentic Philly cheesesteak before I headed back to the South, seen this on Google and read the reviews so decided to order. Absolutely amazing portions you could easily split the sandwich and fries with 2 people, GREAT prices, the Cesar salad was 10/10. Fries were some of the best I’ve had and please don’t get me started on how delicious the Philly was. I was only jealous that i won’t be here during the week where they do happy hour and have 50% off different items everyday during the week, with already amazing prices that’s a deal! Highly recommend if you’re reading this, run don’t walk to this spot!

Phenomenal and affordable local deli that really cares about its products, customers, and staff. Goodfellas has quickly become a staple place for me to order from. The food always arrives to me fast, and hot, and at an unbeatable price as well. I’ve really enjoyed everything I’ve ordered so far and they always treat me like family. Definitely recommend.

Philly guy who just moved to Jersey. Stopped here to eat from a hard day doing pest control. Figured their itallian hoagie was good so ordered it and paid $16. It was a lousy rip-off and not worth the price. Hardly any meat and the girl over-killed it with lettuce and onions which took up the whole sandwich. This place sucks. Do not eat here!

Tried this place today. I ordered the Siciliano and a cheesesteak hoagie. The Siciliano had barely any chicken on it. Everything was chopped up and looked like mush. My husband took one bite and threw it out. The cheesesteak hoagie meat had no taste and the tomatoes were cut so thick. This was the worst spot we have ordered from in New Jersey.