Gionino's Pizzeria of Pickerington

Pretty bummed tonight. Spent a bunch of money on raw pizza. First medium was super under cooked. That’s not cheese in the picture it’s raw mushy dough. Got a remake which is the second pic. The staff was cool about it and responsive…but the middle of the second pizza is still raw. The large we had was slightly under in the middle too but I just tossed that in our own oven. Medium was super raw. Only even leaving this comment because the fix was still not fixed and it’s too expensive to get half or 2/3 cooked pizza. Edit: Selena and I connected and she made everything right. Had an opportunity to eat there tonight and everything was excellent. Thanks Gioninos!

Ordered from here for years! Recently my pizza was slightly undercooked. The bottoms felt wet and soggy. Really hope they get it together. Also ordered some jojo fries and the place never called me to tell me the fryer was down until I got there! Management do better please. Flavor still on point but service needs work. Place used to be so good.

I ordered a Deluxe Pizza and it barely had any toppings except Pepperoni. Also make sure to order it well done. Last time I did not order well-done and it was doughy. This time it was cooked well but barely had toppings.

My spouse and I just moved to the Pickerington area. We ordered a large pepperoni and mushrooms pizza with a side of Buckeye BBQ wings. It was all amazing!! Have not had wings with that much meat and crunch at pizza joint. Also yhe pizza was so flavorful with just the right amount of sauce. The cheese had an amazing pull and was so good as well. Hats off Gionino's!

Recently attended the Pickerington Pizza challenge and really liked their best pizza. First time we’ve ever ordered a pizza from this store, ordered the best pizza, but it wasn’t the same. Not nearly as good as what they served at the challenge. Not sure what was different. Wasn’t bad, but just was not as delicious as the one we had there.