Gentili's Pizza & Steaks

Stopped here 12/20/2025 for dinner around 7pm with my fiancée. Upon walking in the restaurant we were greeted with an amazing aroma of freshly baked pizzas! I had planned to get one of their cheesesteaks with onions. Sadly they were sold out of their rolls but staff were able to make it a wrap! My fiancée had The Luigi (again a wrap). Both were absolutely fantastic! We also got the Meatball Trio as an appetizer which was nothing short of amazing. I opted for a specialty slice of pizza as well (again, wow!). We ordered personal size pizzas to go (fiancée got plain but added prosciutto and hot honey, I got The Corleone). While the food is awesome, it’s really the service that stuck out to us both. Everyone was helpful and constantly checked on us to make sure everything was up to o

After seeing many great reviews for Gentilli's, I was finally in the area and decided to stop in and see if it loved up to the hype... Boy am I glad I did! Excellent! Cheesesteak is top tier. I would say tied with Johnny's in Bryn Mawr, and Johnny's is my current #1! The roll is just amazing. Lightest crisp to the outside, soft inside. Roll was like it just came out of the oven perfect. Tender beef with no gristle and seasoned perfectly. Perfect amount of cooper sharp and long hots roasted to perfection. 9.8 Pizza also is top tier. Fresh dough flavor with the perfect crisp to the crust. Tomato sauce also had a very light & fresh flavor. Perfect amount of cheese on the pie as well. Also, a generous amount of those aforementioned delicious long hots. 9.1

We live near St Louis and the wanted to try a real authentic Philly Cheese steak sandwich. Our relatives who live in PA suggested Gentili's for the real deal. WOW, what a great sandwich! We also tried some pizza and that was also excellent. I wish they would open a location in St Charles Missouri.

First of all, let me tell you about the aromas when you walk into Gentili’s—AMAZING! If I could bottle that up, I would! Their pizza looks absolutely delicious, but we ordered a cheesesteak and the Luigi hoagie and oh my goodness… the cheesesteak was one of the best we’ve ever had! The Luigi hoagie, with its authentic Italian meats, blew my taste buds away. It had just the right amount of meat, and I still have half left for later. If you’re in the Exton area, do yourself a favor and stop at Gentili’s—you will not regret it!

Was a big fan when they first opened, but it seems to have dropped off in food and service. Last week I ordered a personal Charlie pizza and a slice of Grandma's pizza. The slice was mushy and tasteless, seems to have been sitting out all day. When I got home, I had 2 slices chicken, bacon & ranch. I called about the mistake and was told to come get my pizza, said it would be a few hours. Well when I went there this was the box I got and the pizza sat on the shelf for hours. Should have been given a fresh pizza.