Gelateria Dei Coltelli

Nice cafe with lots of delicious choices of gelato and sweets. It has comfortable seating area to dine in to enjoy the sweet. The staffs here are also very friendly as well. Would definitely want to come visit again!

I tried about 4 flavors of course the vanilla with sprinkles are my favorite. I also had the vegan vanilla which I didn’t really like. I like their regular vanilla and I tried cookies and cream and I think cotton candy like flavor. I would say that their ice cream doesn’t taste like regular ice cream I would say that it taste rich and they’re crepe I didn’t like that much I wasn’t expecting it to be that big. It could’ve had cream in it to be honest because it had a lot of Nutella, but I came back to this place for a few times. It was my first time trying it a few weeks ago. You can go in and sit down inside and they have an outside on the side that you could sit.

Staff extremely unfriendly without a smile, crepe dough, underbaked and tasteless. the gelato is good. If the working girls were nicer, everything would be tastier

Extremely flavorful. Salted caramel and hazelnut are our favorite flavors. We’ve been here twice and the front desk girls have always been extremely helpful and friendly with flavor samples and getting us our ice cream. Service and flavors for gelato cannot be beat. Better than ice cream gelato places in the city and Brooklyn. If you’re in Garden City area- worth the slight drive to get here!!!

This has always been my favorite ice cream/gelato spot, especially in the hot summer months. I’ve been coming here for years, often with my parents. Unfortunately, it feels like the quality is starting to decline. During my recent visit, the environment was extremely loud , so loud that we could barely hear each other. I understand the owners can’t control people’s volume, but the noise level created a very uncomfortable and chaotic atmosphere. It might help to put up a small sign asking guests to be mindful of others and keep conversations at a reasonable volume. Also, the tables were quite dirty. I noticed there were plenty of staff members around, but instead of cleaning, many were chatting with each other. It only takes a few seconds to wipe down a table, and keeping the space clean