Garvan's Gastropub

So much to love about this place. The building itself is so charming! The first floor reflects the Hugenots, while the second floor is more colonial. There is a busy pub on the first floor, but I prefer sitting in one of the smaller, quieter rooms upstairs. The street corn carrots are without question the best carrots I have ever eaten. Honestly, I never knew carrots could taste so good. The leek and potato soup, scallops, and short ribs are also recommended. Service was excellent!

The atmosphere is really quite wonderful. The service is on par. The food however did not live up to my expectations. I had scallops and by the time I returned home my stomach was blowing up. Something not right. This feels like more of a wedding venue than a restaurant service. Really beautiful grounds. But the meal. I think they could do better.

Christmas Eve dinner was absolutely out of this world! The food, service, and atmosphere were all incredible. Everything felt special from start to finish. I’m already looking forward to coming back the next time I’m in New Paltz.

What a beautiful, quiet and picturesque location. Was asked if we wanted to be seated by the bar, dining room or outside. If I knew that it was screened in, I would have most definitely sat outside. Either way, you can’t go wrong wherever you choose and/or are seated as the place is beyond charming. Was in a rush so just had the street corn carrots, Shepherds (has lamb in it) and Shepherdess (is vegetarian) pies and all three dishes were delicious. HOWEVER regardless of your taste buds and regardless of what you are in the mood for you HAVE to order their street corn carrots. O. M. G. PHENOMENAL. EXTREMELY pleasantly surprised. A MUST try. Staff is extremely welcoming.

Wonderful establishment with tasty food, unique atmosphere, and friendly staff (shoutout to Katrina!). We had the short ribs, scallops, and the street carrots - all done incredibly well. You can really feel the love in this place. I highly recommend.