Gaeta's Tomato Pies

Order a pie. Guy comes out. Hand him credit card. Cash only. Go next door they have an ATM. $5+ in fees to use. No thanks. No sign on the door or inside saying cash only. Waste of time.

Phenomenal. Got the roast pork sandwich (only made on the weekends) and the tomato pie. The best roast pork I’ve had in the entire city (potentially one of the best sandwiches I’ve had in all of Philly). Seeded rolls are fantastic and are a must. Authentically Philly vibes and really friendly staff. If you are even remotely in the area you should 1000% come here.

The best Tomato pie in Phila and South Jersey area. Nobody can come close to this style pizza! It’s been around since the early 70’s in Germantown and then moved to Northeast Philly. Only complaint is wished they delivered their pies to Camden County area.

I decided to go try this place strictly off the reviews. I never grabbed my phone so fast to write one. I will always try a place no matter the reviews unless it’s something ridiculous, and seeing all these positive reviews I know why I don’t trust any review across all platforms. I ordered half sheet of their most popular square tomato pie. I hate saying this about food, but it was disgusting. The dough was hard like a rock not because it’s made to be crispy, but because whoever is making the dough probaly worked for Elios at some point in their career. That’s what this pizza reminded me of minus the cheese. No air in the dough what’s so ever. Dough can be airy and crispy, and neither does it need to be really thick for it to become airy. The sauce the most disgusting part reminded of Bo

This is a gem of a pizza place. Been around for a century. Best of the best Square Tomato Pies, Round Pies, Stromboli's and all spectacular.