Fresh Catch Fish Market & Grill

We had an excellent dinner here. I had the crab cake sandwich, which was a quality lump crab meat with no fillers. Perfection. My husband and son both had the lobster roll, which was also delicious. They only offer key lime pie for dessert, and when it's this good that's all they need to offer! This is a very small place tucked in an unremarkable strip of shops, but the food is fantastic. We came early for dinner, but I'd say you should make a reservation if eating later. We will most definitely eat here every time we visit Siesta Key.

We found this hidden little gem by searching for a fresh seafood restaurant yesterday. We were celebrating my birthday and all I wanted was some fresh, quality seafood. So we got there early and to our surprise it was pretty much reservations only with a few bar stools open. Kristen our server talked us in to staying, so we sat at the bar. Our food was amazing we had a crab cake dinner (no fillers here) and lightly blackened Cobia. Both were cooked to perfection. They also brought over a slice of their key lime pie (which I am not fond of), it was also very good. Kristen our server kept checking on us to make sure we were good. I highly recommend this little best kept secret. Nothing fancy, just great seafood!

Fresh Catch always has the most amazing food and great service. Their key lime pie is the best in FL. Love this little spot!

Absolutely the freshest seafood you will find. Very casual and friendly Great service. Florida stone crab claws now in season and their stone crab claw bisque is brimming with crab and so fresh and delicious.

We enjoyed our time at Fresh Catch Fish Market. My wife started with the side Caesar salad which she enjoyed. I had the fresh catch fish sandwich. I went with the mahi mahi, sandwich was very good could tell the fish was fresh. I just got it grilled as well so the fish was the star of the show. The coleslaw was very bland, not my favorite. My buddy got the fish tacos, he said they were good. His potatoes looked good as well. My wife got the happy snapper wrap which was really really good we both enjoyed it. Her rice again was very plain and had no flavor. We were talked into the key lime pie which was the first time I’ve had it so not sure what to compare it to. It was solid not my favorite thing but don’t think I’d love any key lime pie. Service was very nice, but to get our checks and pa