First Ave Pizza

DO NOT order from here. They do not know how to cook Italian foods nor are their portions anywhere near other Italian places. $35 dolllars for a stromboli the size of a hot dog bun and garlic bread that was horrible. If you're hungry DO NOT order from this ripoff place. The woman on the phone was rude as well. They'll be out of business within 6 months, guaranteed!

It was fantastic last year when I ordered from here, but it's now mediocre at best. The flavor was subpar, and the dough was undercooked.

RUDE staff. Pizza took TWO hours and staff Hung up on me 2 times before just completely ignoring my calls. Ordered a pizza through their website online, after one hour of not receiving our food we called to check on it. The employee on the phone with us said that it was through Door Dash even though we ordered through the restaurants personal website, She ended up hanging up on us instead of trying to help us figure out the issue. So we called back, obviously annoyed at this point, some man answers and only says “door dash, get it?? Door dash!!” And hung up on us again. Then they ignored all of our calls. We called door dash and they didn’t have any order for us. Super unprofessional. Food was okay but won’t ever order from them again, If the business owner knows what’s good for them, the

This place is completely overpriced and they know it. Basically they just take advantage of drunk people in their 20s. Also the pizza is terrible. Chicken rolls are ok tho. $13 for a chicken roll is outrageous

Don’t listen to these negative comments! Pizza was delicious, friendly staff. My family came to Manasquan to get pizza on a Saturday night and Gee Gees was closed. On a Saturday?! We found this place and ordered a pizza and it was ready in 9 mins. We brought it to the boardwalk and had a delicious dinner!