Fireside Tavern Sherborn

The restaurant was absolutely amazing and such a pleasure to go to. The food was top-notch in the service was even better. I would highly recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for a casual date, a business meeting, a place to go out for the evening, or just to simply grab a bite to eat. I’m from South Carolina and I would travel all the way up there just for another bite, it’s that good!

This hidden gem is Sherborn is the perfect blend of historic charm and modern comfort. The bar lounge has a great vibe - perfect for gathering with friends or a fun date night. The drink menu is extensive - the sangria tops my list. You must have the cornbread app and the fish dishes are divine. The staff always makes you feel at home. They may even sing Happy Birthday to special guests!

My husband and I were there for Valentines Day We ordered the specials My husband had the Sole with a veloute sauce. The veloute sauce was thick and pasty, when it should have been lighter than a gravy. My filet mignon was sitting on a mushroom gravy which was also thick and glutinous. The fish and filet were both excellent but the sauces were a major disappointment. We loved the bambam shrimp. We will try again and maybe just order from the regular menu

First time here. Cozy, small-town vibe and a solid neighborhood bar/restaurant. Nothing flashy, but comfortable. Service at the bar started out great. Unfortunately, while we were having cocktails, a cockroach crawled right in front of us and the bartenders. They apologized, and we moved on. These things happen. A few minutes later, just before our food arrived, another one passed by. This time the bartender apologized profusely and told us (multiple times) that our meal would be comped, and later also offered dessert on the house. When the bill came, only the dessert was comped. When I politely mentioned what we’d been told, the waitress gave us attitude and then comped the meal, but removed the dessert comp. Money wasn’t the issue. It was the inconsistency and the way it was handled.

I couldn't wait to try this place out and I'm glad I did! We sat on the bar side dining room. Two TVs and a touch loud but a beautiful room. Caroline was our server and she was wicked nice! She also knew her menu. For apps, we ordered bbq chicken wings, potato skins, and cauliflower. All the apps were amazing! The cauliflower one was incredible!!! For dinner I got fish and chips. The breading on the fish was delicious and the fries were also good. Also came with coleslaw. I don't eat coleslaw. My wife got the burger and she said it was incredible! Our friend got the vegetable pasta and that was also amazing. For dessert, we split a cheesecake and carrot cake. Both were amazing! Prices are more than fair for the portions you get, the service, and the ambiance! I would highly recommend this