Fenwick Ice Cream Co.

We couldn’t resist getting some ice cream from Fenwick after having lunch at Johnny Ad’s! They have a bunch of flavors to choose from, and all of the ice cream is handmade by them. We indulged in a banana split, and it came with all of the classic toppings, and our friends enjoyed the mint chip and toasted almond. It was a cute, casual spot, and the girls at the window were friendly. This was our second time getting ice cream here and we will definitely be back for more!

Yummy homemade ice cream, spent the day the afternoon in old saybrook. Ended up getting a s'mores and salted caramel ice cream on a waffle cone.

Adorable ice cream shop with amazing vibes! The place is so cute and inviting, and the staff is beyond sweet and helpful. Tons of fun flavors and everything tastes incredible. A perfect spot for a treat we’ll definitely be coming back! 🍨💖✨

Perfect is an understatement… The staff and owner of Fenwick Ice Cream are some of the kindest most down to earth folks around. Everything is top notch, clean and absolutely delicious. I pulled in 30mins past closing with no hopes of getting ice cream after dinner, the owner saw me, opened the door and happily scooped my party of 3 some amazing ice cream. Wish I could give 100 stars. Absolutely the best ice cream establishment in the area. Thank you Fenwick Ice Cream!!

Their chocolate mousse ice cream is easily the best ice cream I've ever had. I will be dreaming about it for days to come. The service was also extremely friendly. There was plenty of room to sit and chat while we enjoyed our ice cream. This was the perfect end to a day out!