Fattie G’s Pizzeria

Love this place! I travel a lot and I visit pizza places everywhere I go, so I’m pretty picky with my pizza. Been in WNY for a while this year and I’ve been striking out with pizza, until I found Fattie G’s. Sauce is good, crust is good. Great cheese. They’re CONSISTENT. I can’t stress how important consistency is and they nail it. Portions are generous and fairly priced. You can tell he makes things how he would want them if he were the customer. The staff is literally so great every time. Talked with the owner himself and he seems like a great guy who is more concerned with making awesome food and being involved with the community, than simply getting in your pocket to make a dime or two. Love that. I’ve been here nearly a dozen times and it’s great every time. Will continue to return

We have been getting our food from Fattie G's for awhile now, since switching from the "other" pizza place near them and they never disappoint in service, delivery or quality of their food. Yesterday I ordered their sheet and bucket and when the delivery guy arrived, he said we are giving you a large pizza free because we messed up your order and placed mushrooms on the while pizza, not just 1/2. Pretty awesome service ! Way to go, and thanks! See ya's again real soon!!

I just called to place an order for a small cheese & 1/2 pepperoni pizza and other food! remind you it’s Sunday February 8, 2026 at 4:45 pm. I was just told I couldn’t order a pizza until after 6:00pm because they’re too busy! Well good luck! Just know I don’t need your service! Good Bye!

A 100% recommend great food. Great employees. Owner works hard at what he built i don't believe that man takes time off. Thank you guys for being such a amazing establishment, WITH AMAZING FOOD.

Stopped in randomly for a couple slices, never noticed the place before and I drive this route frequently. Glad I did, this is real deal Buffalo pizza. I grew up in the city so I'm a snob. Sauce sweet n tangy, peperoni real deal cup n char, dough delicious (mind you this was a slice pie and may have been out of the oven a bit) and still good. Oh and real deal Buffalo Blu cheese. I'm in Lake View and will 100% drive the 10 15 minutes for it again. Forgive my photography I was busy enjoying. Definitely give it try.