Fat City BBQ

First time great experience! The girl that answered phone was kind and efficient! Super nice upon arrival! Food was bagged perfectly! Chicken sandwich was perfect ! The roll, coleslaw and pickle on the side is worth every cent! 10/10

This is the second time I had to drive to Horseheads, NY for work and the 2 hour drive was worth it because I got to eat at Fat City again! The staff is amazing and I enjoyed my lunch of burnt ends, corn bread (definitely the best I’ve ever had, it was so moist that it tasted like cake!) mac & cheese, baked beans and apple pie, unfortunately they didn’t have the peanut butter pie which is to die for! I loved their bbq so much that I had to order a full slab of ribs with their incredible side dishes for my family to enjoy when I got back to Buffalo. Dinner was a hit, thank you Joe and all the staff at Fat City again!

%100 recommended. Honestly there were 5 out of 5. I was driving from Princeton NJ to Toronto Canada and just I googled Brisket and I saw they are 4.9 star which they deserve to have 5 . Also thank you for google service to guide me here 👌🏻

Called and placed and order was greeted as I walked through the door by friendly staff. This is a nice little building on the edge of Elmira heights and horseheads/big flats. I ordered a Mac daddy platter it was very good and I will be back for it again. It also came with a side piece of cornbread it was very fresh and probably the best piece of cornbread I ever had. Overall 10/10 will be back again.

The ribs were fall off the bone amazing. The chicken collard greens were flavourful and the corn bread was moist.