Fat Baby's Pizza & Subs

The food was decent but the restaurant itself was dirty. Food stuck on the napkins container, salt, pepper, sauce containers and table. Server was just ok. Would not recommend.

We ordered this in for delivery and it was great! If you need a night in with the family and don’t feel like cooking, this is a good place for something easy. We enjoyed the margarita, sausage, and pepperoni pizzas. Our favorite was the sausage!

We came here because one of our friends referred us. We are from Kansas City and when we walked in around 2 PM nobody was in the place except for 2 people at the bar. At 1st we were asking ourselves where is everyone? We spoke to Jennifer our server and she said it gets busy around 4 PM. We were actually lucky since we got good parking. The pizza was outstanding and my wife had a very healthy salad. It was one of the best firewood pizza's I've ever had and it was not burned at all. Outstanding food and service.

We didn’t eat in so can’t really rate the atmosphere but the pizza and mozzarella “balls” we really good. The mozzarella tasted homemade and was really crispy. Pizza could have used just another min or two in the oven and the marinara sauce container was half full but that could just be because of take out. We will definitely be back again to eat in this time!

This Place is Legit! Alright, so if you're on Hilton Head Island and lookin' for some grub that hits different, you gotta check out Fat Baby Pizza and Subs. This spot ain't playin' around when it comes to food that satisfies. Their pizzas? Straight fire. They load 'em up with toppings, and the cheese is always on point. That crust ain't flimsy either – it's got that perfect crisp, no flop. And the sauce? Bangin'. It just ties everything together for a perfect slice every time. But trust, it ain't just about the pizza. Their subs are no joke either. We're talking fresh ingredients, good meat, and bread that holds up. That Italian cold cut sub? Pure 🔥. They've got the whole menu on lock, from wings to calzones, so there's always something to get into. The vibe in there is chill, super la