Fairport Harbor Creamery

It's not an exaggeration to say this is the best ice cream I've ever had. It's so smooth, and the flavors were strong and so good! We got a sampler with Strawberry, Blueberry Crumble, Banana Cream Pie, and Dark Chocolate Chip. My favorite was the banana cream pie - which is usually a strong yummy flavor as-is, but this one was over the top. Strawberry was a strong second. Usually strawberry ice cream has that weird fake flavor you taste in Nesquik and such, but not here - this was a super strong natural-tasting flavor. I'd love this in a shake. We also got cookie dough pieces which were delicious too.

Beautiful shop. Amazing ice cream. Terrific staff!! Friendly and kind.

Great ice cream place. I recommend the Sampler to share with your date. You can enjoy four flavors.

Visited during a busy time of the evening and a warm sunny day, cookies &cream double scoop, alongside mint chocolate chip double Scoop and a kids size vanilla ice cream in a cup topped with sprinkles. The service was prompt despite the business and wait to order. Overall I am satisfied with the customer service and the quality of the ice cream!

Beautiful building with a large selection of ice cream and sundaes and other treats. I had a single scoop of cookie dough in a cake cone and it was excellent!