Emiliano's Pizza

I’ve shared a review before after visiting with my parents-in-law, and I’m happy to say Emiliano’s continues to impress. Today I stopped in to try something new and ordered the Emiliano Special White Slice with prosciutto and arugula. I was encouraged to add a bit of blue cheese crumble, and it took the slice to another level. The food is consistently well made, the service is always great, and it’s such a pleasure to have a place like this so close to home. Truly delicious, and highly recommended to anyone in the area! 🍕Full disclosure: the slice shown in the photo is only half of the actual slice. Emiliano’s slices are generously sized, and I shared the other half with a loved one 😉

9/13/25 We were here for the weekend for an assembly. We ordered around 6pm on Saturday for pickup. A large pepperoni, steak and cheese stromboli, and turkey club hoagie. Everything was really great! The pizza was delicious. The steak and cheese was packed full and the hoagie was really stuffed with turkey and bacon! Great restaurant and we'll be coming here for every assembly at the Newburgh Hall from now on 😃 The order came to $48.

Great family-owned pizza shop with huge number of options, all of which are great. The slices are huge and what’s even better is that I’m the vibe is very much a neighborhood shop not trying to gouge the customer but serving great pizza. The drinks are also priced ridiculously cheep. I was shocked that two slices of gourmet pizza and a can of soda only ran me $12.

Came visiting from Canada on the hunt for some good pizza from NY...This was awesome! The atmosphere is nice, most seem to take out but inside is a nice homey place with seats up to 4 per table it seems. Service was great, very polite and friendly cashier as well as waiter. The slices we got were excellent. Pictured is the Honey Hot Pepperoni which was mesmerizing. The Margherita Pizza was really fresh. The chicken terriyaki was also really good. The variety is great and the prices are especially good. Definitely a must try.

I love their pizza and every Monday my husband and I order the same thing cause it's delectable. For us, it's a standing Monday night order, forever, of the most delectable, sexy tasting pizza. Thanks guy's for keeping Monday pizza night going for the order going to 131 6. My only teeny tiny problem is that they say they close at 10, but after a certain time they stop answering the phone. My question is why?