Eldridge Family Sugar House & Ice Cream Shoppe

This was worth the 2 hour trip 🤣 We went out of our way to visit and it was amazing. The “breakfast for dessert” ice cream (maple soft serve, puffle cone, Cinnamon Toast Crunch, maple syrup) was out of this world. Dog friendly (they have pup friendly ice cream), family owned, and you can see where they tap their trees behind the seating area, which was pretty cool!

everything we got was 10/10. It was quaint and cute setting! It was about 25 outside of Conway, and it was ABSOLUTELY worth the drive. The drive offered lots of foliage and lake views which is a plus. If you’re debating just do it! & the prices were incredible for what you get.

Very nice offerings. Creamy and delicious, craveable flavor. Gifford’s hard ice cream also on offer. We only came for the maple soft serve. The shop inside was closed as it was already evening. Long line and cars parked on road let us know this place was popular for a reason. Staff was quick and professional, tired, but not overwhelmed. They are busy busy. So be patient and nice. The puffle cone sells out daily, and this time the customers in front of us got the last one! Now we have to come back!!

Eldridge Family Sugar House & Ice Cream Shoppe is an absolute treasure! If you’re a fan of maple, you have to try their maple soft serve—it’s unbelievably creamy, perfectly sweet, and full of rich maple flavor that tastes like it came straight from the tree. It’s hands-down the best maple soft serve I’ve ever had. You can tell everything is made with care and love. The staff is friendly and welcoming, and the whole place has that warm, small-town charm that makes you want to come back again and again. Whether you’re passing through or making a special trip, this spot is 100% worth the stop!

The hype and ratings are all worth it. Feels like the Maple OG. I can’t recommend Eldridge Family Sugar House & Ice Cream Shoppe enough! This place is a hidden gem, and I’m so glad we stumbled upon it. "Breakfast for Dessert" Ice Cream: The “Maple Creme” here is THE best ice cream I’ve ever had in my entire life. I can’t even begin to describe how delicious it is. The texture was smooth and creamy, and the maple flavor was perfectly balanced—rich without being overwhelming. Honestly, it was so addictive that I couldn’t get enough of it. If you’re anywhere near this place, you absolutely have to try it. Service: The service was fantastic, with friendly and welcoming staff. I had the pleasure of chatting with the couple running the shop, and they were incredibly warm and kind. It’s clear t