El Maguey Mexican Restaurant

Me and hubby go here often. The staff provides great service every time. We love the maguey dip and street tacos. Definitely the best place to eat in southern Indiana in our opinion. Special thanks to Sammi for being the best waitress.

Excellent food! Easily the best Mexican food I’ve had in the area! Even the kids loved it. It was actually my 12 year old that complimented the flavor of the chicken and cheese and compared it to other Mexican restaurants. My youngest really enjoyed his chicken tenders and he is picky. Well worth the money. The atmosphere is unique as well. Beautifully decorated and original.

I used to go here 4-5 days a week but the owner got rid of the old bartender and got a new one. The new one is absolutely rude no personality and can’t make a drink at all. So Istarted going 3 days week and after last night I doubt I’ll ever go again. I got there a little after 8pm and the staff at 945 started cleaning moving booths sweeping by 1015 they were stacking chair. Mind you I/we were still eating and still had our drinks. There were three services that told me/us we didn’t have to leave take our time that they didn’t close till 10:30 but we did not feel welcome and we felt rushed. Food is great but definitely going down hill with the new bartender and atmosphere

I have been to this place many times beginning in October 2019 and during the summer of 2020. My friends and I visit here on Tuesdays typically and we LOVE the rooftop dining terrace here at El Maguey Mexican Restaurant in Salem Indiana. Sometimes I space out on cloud nine at sunset and dusk because the atmosphere is so enjoyable. The owner is so passionate about creating a relaxing atmosphere and pleasant hospitality experience for her customers. The decor and design of this restaurant are an ongoing evolution but it keeps getting better because the passion the owner has to communicate to her customers that she cares about their experience as they visit her restaurant. If you visit this place as often as I do, you'll notice that even the building itself has a soothing personality th

This place turned out to be a great find. The restaurant ambiance is perfectly suited for a good experience. The service was friendly, helpful, and prompt! I can't say enough about the food. Great flavors throughout our meal. This is a family friendly place that you will enjoy!