Eddies Pizza

Wow terrible pizza! I have never seen so much oil and pepperoni on a pie. Garlic knots were undercooked! I called the pizzeria to file a complaint and all I received was terrible customer service, gentleman seemed offended and he yelled and screamed over the phone and just hung up. If you are going to run a business you need to be prepared for all feedback the positive and the negative point blank. Disgusting human being, what a waste of my money. Please do not order from here.

Local pizzeria been around for the 30 years that I've lived in lake ronkonkoma. Reliable and consistent food, but it's their prices that are simply staggering $28.99 for everything in this photo

Tried to call in an order for the Monday night food special(was posted on your Instagram page 2 hours prior) and was told you "sold out" of the special. What did you run out of? The pizza, the pasta or the garlic knots? Won't be ordering from here again. Very shady.

They were amazing! I called in the morning and asked if they could make a pizza shaped like the number 4 for my sons birthday. I didn’t plan ahead and did it that day. They made it and were so sweet about it. The pizza was good. I had no complaints, they even asked if I wanted them to trim the edges to make it perfect. Really happy about the customer service!

We'd gone to another late-night pizza place but they were out of cheese slices. On a whim, we tried this one in a mini shopping plaza next to King Kugel. Happy to say the server had an entire cheese pie to reheat 2 slices from. Slices were vintage NY. So we pushed our luck & ordered spaghetti & meatballs to go, which wasn't as good. Decent though. Tomato sauce was too sweet & meatballs had way too much chunky bread filler. At the time, they were doing a live Facebook stream for a drawing & seemed to have fun.