Dutch Haven Shoo-Fly Pie Bakery

Fantastic - we popped in and thoroughly enjoyed the shop. The staff were so friendly and the food absolutely divine. I had never seen a Shoofly Pie before - but that did not stop me from purchasing a large one (much to my wife's amusement) and I enjoyed every last mouthful

My go-to place for Shoo-fly pie... always looks the same in store, very few upgrades or additions over the years. Worth a visit for Amish goods and gifts.

Very friendly and nice people that work here. Like a mom and pop store that serves you pie or various food stuff. Lots of trinkets and crafts as well. A nice stop for a snack. No seating though, except for some rocking chairs in the back room.

Stopped by to grab some pies and treats. Woman working were fabulous and food was amazing. Definitely would recommend a stop by to pick yourself up some treats.

This was my first time trying shoo-fly pie so I wanted to get it homemade somewhere in Amish country. It was really good; not sickeningly sweet like some gooey pies can be. The ice cream was good too. The coffee was just okay. Next door is an awesome vintage/antique/handmade store with two stories, full of cute vintage books, jewelry, decor, kitchenware, clothes, stickers, and more. I could wander around for hours!