Cusumano's Pizza & Food Company

I hate leaving bad reviews for local, small business owned shops, but our first experience at this location was less than ideal. I tried calling to place the order, but the phone just rang until it went to voicemail. I went ahead and ordered online and noted for our meat lovers pizza that we wanted to swap the pepperoni for hamburger because of allergies. I was nervous about them not being able to get this note so I used the chat feature to send in a communication, but never heard back. Despite their being a note on their order ticket and the ticket on the box, the employees did not make the pizza as requested. They were extremely friendly, and the pizza was still very good for me, but if they don’t follow the note submitted on the order they really seems to be no purpose for it.

Walked into this pizza place with no idea what to expect. The st louis style pizza was delicious. We loved the personable Gina. She was so welcoming and has a passion for her pizza. We will definitely be back!!! Yummmy!

Cusumano’s Pizza in Warrenton seriously impressed me. I ordered The Alexander, which is their version of a supreme, and it was outstanding. The toppings were generous, everything tasted fresh, and the balance of flavors was on point. What really got me was the Provel. If you’re from the St. Louis area, you know exactly what I mean. It has that classic St. Louis Hills vibe and honestly rivals Imo’s. It even gave me a little Joe Bacardi’s nostalgia, which is saying something. The crust had the perfect texture (though a little burnt), the sauce was flavorful without overpowering the toppings, and the whole pie just worked. You can tell they care about what they’re putting out. I’ll absolutely be back for more. Warrenton is lucky to have a spot like this.

I love this pizza joint! Delicious St. Louis style pizza with cracker thin crust! A small cozy spot perfect for date nights or take out. The dining area is small with two person seating. So no big parties or loud environments. Sam, the owner came out to check on us during dinner. He is kind and personable. I can't wait to go back!

First time in Cusumano’s last night and it was excellent. Service by everyone was great, and the owner personally ensured we were taken care of. The garlic bread is some of the best around and the spaghetti and meatballs were as good today as they were last night. Nice to have really good, local restaurants to choose from in Warrenton!