Custer's Cones & Candy Chetek

The staff recommended the Munchie Madness and it was awesome. Great ice cream and candy shop! The homemade waffle cones were still warm and very delicious! I would highly recommend stopping in.

While on vacation in June 2025 we stopped in here twice. Ice cream is delicious and creamy, and the staff was friendly both times. They have free samples to try to ice cream before you buy, which was great because they offer so many unique flavors. Tip: the One scoop is actually like Two scoops. There is also bulk candy you can buy. A big variety of taffy, chocolates, and gummies. Definitely try this place is you love ice cream!

My husband & I had the pleasure of introducing my sister, brother in law and niece to Custer's last night for the 1st time. EVERYTHING was absolutely delicious. I was so happy to see there was even a full cooler of dairy free options. I got the black cherry oat (I assume oat milk base) and it was SO CREAMY and delicious. If I didn't know better I would have thought it was regular ice cream. Nice to go someplace and have options to enjoy with my family. My niece (10 yrs old) asked if we can go back again and again and again because there's so many flavors she wants to try. The girls helping us were SO wonder too. My sister and BIL had their family dog, Bernie, with us and the girls gave us a "pup cup" for him. Bernie the cavapoo ate his pup cup and greeted people as we sat and enjoyed our i

Enjoy the ice cream, very good quality and some of the greatest tasting ice cream I've ever had. Thank you staff for making greatest ice cream!

This Candy store is Amazing !! Haven't tried the ice cream - but will when take company visits. Nice selection of chocolate dark & milk, Kid candy ( gummy snakes & frogs), Taffy and Fudge. Happy faces in store...Kids, parents, grandparents all smiling ! Very Pleasant shopping experience : )