Crave Cookies Puyallup

McKenzie and Dalton are the real, real MVPs at Crave. My husband and I have been coming to Crave for less than a year and they already know who we are which is always a comforting and kind gesture. They let us know if a fresh batch will be out in minutes and if you are obsessed with these cookies like we are, then you will definitely want to wait for them. We have also placed orders for their cookie cakes (yes just my husband and I eat this in a day…don’t judge) and they really do care about getting the details right on the frosting. Also if you forget your order they will hit you up with a reminder call so you don’t forget! 5 out of 5⭐️’s I recommend if you have a sweet tooth to come check out the weekly flavors because there is always something new for everyone to enjoy.

The chocolate cookies were absolutely delicious—you can really taste the quality and simplicity of the ingredients, which is refreshing at a time when major companies use over a hundred. The holiday inspired brownie cup dessert was decent as well, though not my personal favorite compared to the standout cookies. I loved the open-space concept of the shop, where you can see directly into the kitchen and watch everything being baked fresh with the right ingredients. The owner was incredibly nice and respectful, and I had a pleasant conversation during my visit. This is a great local business, and it’s one we locals should support.

I HIGHLY RECOMMEND THAT YOU GUYS DONT WASTE YOUR MONEY HERE!!!!!!! My other half and I were super excited to try their new drop and we ordered the 6 pack. We got 3 stuffed cookies and cream, 1 marshmallow mayhem, 1 trickster toffee and 1 brookie way. We ended up spending $25.24 for 6 disgusting cookies!!!! I’m not even over exaggerating. Just hear me out, they could’ve done the right thing by doing something about it, when my other half went in and he was super nice to them. (RED BELOW) I feel like they just gave us an old batch and wanted to get rid of it because they were closing. 1. Stuffed cookies and cream: was super dry and hard like idk what and didn’t even taste fresh at all! 2. Marshmallow mayhem: not fresh and was also dry and literally just like rice crispy inside. 3. Trickste

Just went here for the first time today and WOW these cookies are delicious!! I’ve been on a Crumbl kick for whenever I want a sweet treat and these blew Crumbl’s cookies out of the water! I got the caramel churro cookie and the pistachio chocolate chip. Both were warm, soft, chewy inside and just crisp on the outside. I will definitely be back!

These are by far the best cookies I’ve ever had. Not only are they good, but they rotate flavors (and introduce new ones) every week. I end up coming here almost every week just to enjoy the amazing cookies, but every once in a while I just order an entire cookie cake— yes, it’s that good. Every time I come McKenzie has my order ready and shows me again just to make sure it looks correct. With her and Dalton around, I couldn’t ask for a more friendly/reliable staff. I really appreciate the simple things they do and I look forward to coming every week. If you like amazing cookies and a fantastic crew to get them for you, this is the place for you.