Craig's Cookies

I drove there last week from out of town because I tried them when they first opened and they were amazing. So this time I decided to get a box of 12 cookies for $36. Sadly this time the cookies were SOOOOOOOOO salty that they tasted like someone made them with salt instead of sugar! I was sick all night after eating just one cookie! I thought about bringing them back to the store, but they didn't give me a receipt and I threw out the Craig's box already. I also didn't want to waste more gas and parking money and time to drive back there again without any proof that those salty things were from Craig's. I should've trusted the other reviews that mentioned they were salty, but those reviews were from a few months ago and I didn't think it was possible for cookies to be so salty that IT WA

Super cute bakery!! The staff member so was sweet, I asked what was available for warm cookies and both options were SO yummy! I tried two warm and gooey delicious cookies. I would def go back when in the area :)

We ordered a dozen cookies and honestly they were just mediocre at best... especially for the price. The main base for the cookies seemed far too salty and didn't really taste like a top notch recipe. They were more like cookies that an amateur, at-home baker would make using a recipe they got from the internet that's not quite right. Then they add a ton of extras such as M&Ms etc. on top or into to make them "gourmet". They really are not. You'd be better off just ordering from Tim Hortons.

So good! I got lucky and got mine fresh out the oven (the Toblerone cookie) we also got 2 others which were just as amazing. It was cooked perfectly, super soft, and the chocolate just melted in your mouth. The cookies were so chunky and the perfect size, definitely coming back!

I received a box of Craig’s cookies as a Father’s Day gift. Very delicious. I had never heard of a butter tart cookie. Genius idea.