Coy's Pizza Shop

The cheese blend doesn't go with the pizza..Who puts cheddar with pineapple?? Wrecks the flavor profile into the ground. Also I ordered a veggie pizza and received a white pizza. Not what i wanted at all, also had hair under the pizza in the box🤮 Would not recommend to an enemy..

I do not know who the manager or register person was today, 3/7/26, around 1:30 this afternoon, but it was not the normal service I've been receiving for the past 7 years. I ordered a small pizza with pepperoni and extra sauce. I asked for a cup of sauce. The person taking the order says, "So you don't want any sauce on the pizza, just on the side?" No, honey, I want extra sauce on the side. She calls over the manager, and I'm told that I can't have a cup of sauce, just the small cups, so do I want six? I left shaking my head. Do better!

I’ve moved away from the area several years ago, and still talk about this pizza and how great it is. This weekend I came out to visit some friends and family and I was stoked to stop by and get some of this pizza while I was here. It still tastes just as great as when I was last there. The crust is robust and thick! Great for how much they load up the pizza with. There’s always so much cheese and toppings that you NEED to have a hearty dough. But it’s soft all the way to the crust. Perfectly cooked and perfectly adorned with cheese and sauce. I’m sad that I no longer live around here so it might be a while before I can eat another one of their great pizzas. So please. Go there for me. And get one pizza of each perogie, bbq chicken, Buffalo chicken.

I’m from Philly and I’m a pizza man. Since I moved to Indiana, it was hard to find a pizza shop. I when I go to Johnstown, I alway see this pizza spot. So today , I stop pass there because they had a good rating. It was good and when I ask for extra pizza sauce , they actually put extra pizza sauce on it. Thank you and yall will be seeing me again good job

Buffalo chicken pizza was pretty good! Beer prices were a bit pricey though. Chicken salad was not great, I would just avoid that altogether.