Cottage Inn Pizza Allendale

Cottage inn makes quality, delicious pizza without breaking the bank. I find their crust delicious with a lot of flavors to pick from, and they are generous with the cheese. Their ranch is also amazing, right up there with jet’s ranch. For deep dish jet’s rules, but for hand tossed cottage inn is my go to. Give it a try, they have specials/coupons all the time. This location’s delivery has also always been on time.

Amazing experience from start to finish. The food was fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with care. Portions were generous, presentation was on point, and everything came out hot and perfectly cooked. The staff was friendly, attentive, and made us feel welcome without being overbearing. The atmosphere was comfortable and inviting, making it a great spot for both casual dining and special occasions. Definitely a place I’ll be coming back to and recommending to others.

Deliver driver blew a red light and almost hit me. Then blew through 4 more light before no blinker merging. No blinker turned in front of 4 cars. Proceeds to drive 45-50 down a 25mph residential road. Parks in the middle of the road to deliver pizza. Have the whole thing on dash cam plus got pictures of your sign on top of the car along with its face. Will be forwarding the footage to authorities. The driver was in a Red Rord Focus. PLATE# EYN 4764. No pizza is worth killing someone over.

I've been a big fan of Cottage Inn since I lived in Lansing way back. It's the Cuban Pizza that I will literally drive an hour to get! The funny thing is the pizzas in Lansing were so good and I told the owner that. He laughed and asked me which one I got pizza from in Lansing. I told him and he said small world because he was the manager at that time. That instantly told me I was going to get the best Cuban Pizza and I was NOT disappointed! Will be back soon after I finish up that and the Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza. Definitely a win for you and your appetite!

Cottage Inn Pizza was a great find! We tried the Hot Honey Chicken Pizza, Feta Bread, and The Favorite Pizza—everything was delicious. The hot honey pizza had just the right balance of heat and flavor, and their ranch is seriously tasty. It feels like the best parts of all the major pizza chains rolled into one, with great variety and quality. Prices were reasonable and our order was ready quickly, even on a busy Saturday night. I was a little bummed to see the Cuban pizza is no longer on the menu, and I wish pickles were an option for build-your-own, but I’m still excited to try more of their pizzas soon!