Cookie Jar Bakeshop and Eatery

Very happy with the wedding cake they did for us. Stunning display, tasted fantastic and fresh, had multiple flavors by layer, and the entire thing was Gluten Free but didn't taste weird. Our guests devoured the cake and raved about wanting to try the different flavors. The cookies were great as well and disappeared quickly... thank you again!

Mrs Shana and her crew are Amazing. Thank you from the bottom of our hearts for the best planner service and for making such a Beautiful wedding cake and cookies and delicious desserts for our wedding on June 28th 2025. We highly recommend Cookie Jar cakes in Bartow, FL. Her kindness and Friendship will be forevermore. She goes the extra mile and cares about her staff and her clients. Please go taste her wonderful desserts, and we recently ate at her location the Tuna is Devine and all the foods we have tried are worth coming for a visit and believe us. My hubby and I will always be back and make it a tradition to come eat and enjoy your cakes cookies and foods. Excellent job always. You made our wedding shine bright. Thank you. Love Mark & Brandee Slivka

Our first time here. The cheese cake was really yummy but I can't imagine I will ever buy it again at $11 for such a small slice. The pumpkin bar was okay. Again, the chocolate chip cookie dough cheesecake was really good! I just am not over the shock of how much it was. My fault for just ordering and not looking up at the prices. Now that i know, I can't justify another slice.

We ordered my nieces first birthday cake. They truly delivered. I gave them picture of the decore and one inspiration cake picture and she created a beautiful birthday cake which was also absolutely delicious. We did traditional vanilla with strawberry filling and simple cupcakes which they made look gorgeous. Everyone loved the cake and the cupcakes! The ordering process was very pleasant and easy. We’re new to the area and having a family bakery is important glad we found this one!

I cannot recommend The Cookie Jar enough! After my original wedding baker backed out, Shana swooped in and completely saved the day. She was absolutely amazing to work with—so accommodating, flexible, and genuinely enthusiastic about her craft. You can truly taste Shana's passion in every single bite. She put together a stunning dessert charcuterie spread that was beautifully decorated and featured everything we could imagine: chocolate-covered Oreos, chocolate-dipped pretzels, pistachio cake, and tiramisu just to name a few offerings we indulged in. If you have a sweet tooth or are planning a wedding, you absolutely have to stop by The Cookie Jar. Shana’s passion and talent made our wedding so much sweeter!