Cookie Cow

Run don’t walk to this ice cream shop! They have THE best dairy free ice cream ever! It is so creamy, absolutely delicious and hard to believe is dairy free. You will not be able to tell. The portion sizes are huge. A a great value for your money. It is cutely decorated and the customer service is excellent. Instagram friendly 😃 Highly recommend!! Ice cream tried: peanut putter and cookie (dairy free) and salted caramel

We brought our daughters here to celebrate their birthday and it was an amazing experience! The ice was delicious and so creamy! The cookies are homemade in-house every morning and it totally shows! They were fresh, fluffy, gooey, and delicious!!! Plus there is a shop area attached that had all kinds of games for kids to play from Velcro darts to peg board games! It was fun for all of us and a delicious way to celebrate. The staff was all very friendly and appreciative of our business! 10/10 highly recommend!

Really good value. Seems to be family owned. We split a peach cobbler and it was great, the ice cream had the taste of homemade. No we really like this place.

We went to cookie cow ice cream and absolutely loved it. They have amazing flavors, different floats, and are super friendly. The owners use local to get their products and we have had a discussion about Amish ice cream :-). This will be one of our first stops when my husband comes home for his mid tour :-)

Cookie Cow in Saint Marys is an absolute gem for dessert lovers! Their fresh-made cookies are irresistible, and the locally sourced ice cream perfectly complements the treats. They have at least one dairy free and gluten free ice cream option as well as multiple soda options for an ice cream float. The shop offers plenty of seating, making it a comfortable spot to enjoy your sweet indulgence. Whether you're stopping by for a quick float or a ice cream sandwich, you'll leave craving more. A must-visit for anyone with a sweet tooth!