Conesus Lake Creamery

I can’t recommend this place enough!! The location is fantastic, adjacent to Vitale Park - ideal for walking to the lake with your treat. The menu was comprehensive but not overwhelming, prices were reasonable, and the wait was short. The young lady at the counter let me substitute hard ice cream in my hot fudge sundae and it was lovely. My wife’s banana milkshake was a great flavor and consistency! Great spot, highly recommend.

What a beautiful addition 😍 by the park. Loved the girls were working there. Customer friendly, efficient, and great service. We were there last minute but they well served my whole family. And gave me a beautiful Banana Split. Thanks, Sophie.❤️ great job, ma'am. Finished every bite of it. Will come again. Also, I added a Pic from your guy's pictures because it looked exactly the same. Will come again.

Clean and easy to access from Vitale Park parking as well as behind the shop parking. New paved driveway is smooth. Walk ip window in the back from parking available, or inside seating at front. Some things to know: walk up shelf is marble, which is blazing hot for small hands. Be aware. Sign is too late to see to protect small eager hands. Back may need some umbrellas or cover against sun to fully enjoy. Great location. Perry’s ice cream no surprises. Friendly staff

Amazing ice cream and THE BEST Italian cookies you will find in NY! A well kept establishment and good people!

Rolled in last night at 8:55 pm. Someone saw me and then closed the blinds on the windows, turned the lights off, and disappeared while the "open" sign was still illuminated. Super disappointed, guess ill be going to twisters, --they stay open until 8.