Colony Pizza

Colony Pizza GOOD: Meat pizza toppings were flavorful BAD: Crust and value for price (too high for quantity) Staff is friendly. Colony pizza has a diverse menu that I would give another try. Locals seem to love this place, but I found the pizza very average. The toppings were very good - greasy meats, can't go wrong. I like a nice crispy crust that can support the toppings. Their crust is very soft and chewy. Every slice needs a steady two hands as the crust falls like a limp noodle with any weight. It may sound picky to some, but a good crust really goes a long way and a good, crispy crust that holds toppings well makes for the tasty mix of texture. Also 19 bucks is steep for a 12 inch pie, even with some meats.

Absolutely wonderful!!!!! They have outside seating which is awesome on a beautiful day! Super kind and fast service! Very clean and comfortable establishment! You'll love it! We got 2 pizzas, wings and fries mushrooms! They brought outside to our table! Great Wood fired pizza with quality ingredients you taste! Wings were crispy and saucy if that's how you like em, we do!!!

​"I'm completely sold! I knew this pie was a danger zone, and now I see why I've been avoiding it—it's going to be my new obsession. Eric B., can seriously throw down! This is an absolute must-try, and I'm thrilled it's right up the street. Let's get more!"

I’m not the type to leave bad reviews. Go ahead and check my review history, you’ll see. But with this? I don’t even know where to start. The pizza was super floppy, bordering undercooked. There was more cheese than sauce and crust, so if that’s your thing, more power to you. The sauce was pretty tasty, I’ll give it that, but with a crust that couldn’t support sauce, let alone the pounds of cheese on top, it made eating the pizza a messy pain. So the wings?? Mid. Like so mid that you’re better off going to a chain place like Buffalo Wild Wings. We got the “Southside” flavor, which is supposed to be ranch, cajun, buffalo, and minced garlic. There were some that were decent, but most of the wings were kind of tough, not gonna lie. Like they had that leathery texture to them. And the desse

Wow. Fantastic pizza. Hoagie was delicious. I wouldn't change anything. Whoever said "there isn't any good pizza in Eerie, PA is a damn liar (i said it). The young lady behind the counter was a sweetheart. Took time out and talked to us about the shop and the pizza. This is now my only stop in Eerie for pizza. Great job. Love the decor and the vibe. Don't change a thing!