College Town Pizzeria

This might be some of the best pizza I’ve ever had! We ordered a half order of seasoned fries, the sun-dried tomato and spinach pizza (swapped the sauce for marinara and added chicken), and the cheesesteak calzone — every single dish was a 10/10. Absolutely delicious! Their ranch is yummy too which is always a bonus haha! The staff was incredibly friendly and welcoming, which made the experience even better. So glad we decided to stop here today!

We stopped in for an early dinner on a Sunday afternoon. The 4 of us were the only ones in the restaurant and we waited just over an hour for our food. We weren’t provided any updates and it appeared there were at least 3 folks working. Food portions were not worth the wait. The Strombolis and pizza roll were mostly bread. Sitting area was clean and staff was polite though.

One bite, and everyone knows... I decided to give College Town Pizzeria in Fairbanks another chance to see if they've improved since my first taste in 2015/2016, when they were amazing. However, they went downhill a few years later, and I've been disappointed every time I gave them another chance. This time, I decided to give them another try under new ownership and ordered the classic Smokejumper, but unfortunately, they didn't have smoked mozzarella, so the pizza didn't have that distinct smoky flavor. The pizza was just average, nothing special.

Delicious pizza! Their crust is more on the thin side. I ordered the Diablo breadsticks with ghost ranch and it was great. My only complaint is that I was expecting thick cheese sticks and these were paper thin, but they were still delicious anyway. If you love spicy, try their ghost ranch.

This is the second time eating here and the experience was even better than the first. Ordered the Kulua Pork Pizza. The perfect mixture of pulled pork, pineapple, bacon, jalapeños and a sweet bbq sauce. Excellent choice. Also ordered the Gyro Calazone. Another item I would highly recommend. The restaurant is small and cozy. Service is outstanding. Felt welcomed from the moment we walked in.