Cold Stone Creamery

I ordered a Gotta Have It cake batter with double Butterfinger and Oreo on DoorDash. Eighteen dollars later, I opened the cup to find plain vanilla (wrong flavor) with barely any mix ins. I even shoveled some out just to show how much was missing. There was nothing blended in and none of the toppings I paid for. I honestly can’t understand why something this far off would even be sent out. What makes this more frustrating is that this is the second time in a row this location has done this. The last time was an in-person visit a few months ago. Same issue. Everything was barely mixed, with almost no toppings. I realized when I was getting in my car and I brought it back, and the employee who did not make it seemed confused and immediately fixed it, which is the only reason I decided to gi

I have been going to this Cold Stone for the past few years, and this has got to be my favorite location. Ordering cakes has never been easier. I have ordered a few for myself as well as my family members. The cake decorators do such an amazing job when they decorate the cakes. ( see pictures below) I decorate cakes at home, but I can't imagine how hard it is to decorate ice cream cakes. I remember one birthday cake that I ordered, and the only request I had was that I wanted flowers on my cake; the cake decorator made them so cute. I have arrived a few minutes before they close, and they are always so friendly and willing to serve me and my family. Overall, I have just had an amazing experience, and I look forward to my next visit.

Once acknowledged, I appreciated the women preparing my order within 10 minutes after I realized I had arrived early. I was disappointed with the value of the party pack. I expected the containers to be filled the same as a store bought especially with the price difference. It was treat for my kids, which they did enjoy. Next time, I will drive the extra 15 minutes to belmar.

I love this Cold Stone Creamery. The help.is always super friendly, the location is very clean and I just love to get my favorite cake batter shake each time I visit. Make sure you get it with the yellow cake pieces blended in, so good like that. Thank you Cold Stone Creamery.

I went in about 2 hours ago to buy a quart of my fav, the coffee lover's. This is VERY expensive at $12 a quart. Fast forward to relaxing at home and decide to have a little only to show its not a full quart?!?!?! Guess the teeny bopper was too lazy to fill it. I expect for the amount of money it costs for it to be filled. Now I know to check it....even Dairy Queen has them filled to the rim. Owner responded below but it's not possible to "DM" them with no contact info.