Cold Spring Plaza Delicatessen

After a big hike we were very hungry. Plus we had four dogs with us. Friendly staff made great breakfast sandwiches and spared some extra bacon for our four-legged friends. Thanks so much!

This is an outstanding deli!! Throughout my entire childhood we stopped in multiple times a week and have loved everything! They have an array of fresh foods, or you can order any sandwich you can dream up! Whatever you go with, you will NOT be disappointed! We eventually moved away, so it’s been about 10 years since my last visit, until this past weekend… I cannot believe how little it has changed, which is amazing! Especially in this day & age! rarely will you find a classic, neighborhood deli that has delicious food, friendly staff AND reasonable prices anywhere…. But the CSH Delicatessen is absolutely the place to find ALL of the above!! Thanks to the owner, Nick Tewksbury, who I went to High School with many years ago… this classic deli is still fantastic AND delicious!

The one and only, legendary Cold Spring Harbor Deli. First time back in ~30 years - still excellent. Great staff.

Hidden Gem of a deli. Best egg sandwich on the island!!

Would have left 0 stars, but that wasn’t an option. The worst Italian sandwich I’ve ever seen or had. The amount of meat on this sandwich is criminal. I guess I paid for bread, lettuce, tomato and 2 pieces of meat. Will never go back. Thanks for nothing.