Celeste Bakery

Pre-ordered a custom cake and the process went smoothly and the cake came out as requested I got lemon cake and lemon filling and when I say this was the best cake for my birthday I had ever got. I always get lemon for my birthday but this hit the spot, perfect amount of sweet abs moist. I will definitely get from them again and the bakery is so cute!

I received a cookie platter from this bakery as a gift for Valentine’s Day and all the cookies were DELICIOUS! Will recommend to anyone wanting to get local pastries.

Asked them to make a cake that looked like our dog for wife's birthday. Came out amazing and tasted just as great too. Highly reccomend them for any custom cakes you may want.

What a gem!!! Beautiful, well lit space with absolutely stunning and delicious pastries at very reasonable prices. Each dessert is obviously made with love. I got fruit custard tartes, cannoli, and flan — and all were beyond delicious. The flan was the best I’ve ever had. Can’t wait to return! The star of Riverhead!

Best bakery in the North Fork if you ask me! Absolutely delicious cakes, not the saccharin, very moist and rich, they definitely know what they’re doing.