Cayuga Lake Creamery at The Dewitt Mall

Homemade ice-cream this place is amazing! Pistachio ice cream on their fancy cone is superb and no regrets! Place is cute and pretty with a nice indoor and outdoor spot. Street parking wasn't too bad either. One of the best ice-cream I have had, strong recommend!!

Six stars. I had pistachio and blueberry cheesecake. The pistachio had various sizes of pistachio with only the real taste, no fake pistachio. The blueberry cheesecake was exquisitely creamy. If you can’t decide between two flavors, definitely get them both, it will be worth it.

Homemade ice cream with lots of options. Very tasty and the service was quicker than most of tge ice cream places we go. Staff was friendly. Decor was nice and kids loved it. I had never been. It was a little tricky to find. We parked in a parking garage and walked about a block to get there. Was not marked great, but we did find it. Also, bathroom require a key and you have to leave your phone to get the key. Makes washing up afterwards a little more laborious than should have been.

Top quality homemade ice cream. Highly recommend!

Price, omg. Taste, good. Atmosphere, vibey. I got the maple pecan.