Cathryn's

The service was truly amazing — everyone was so friendly and attentive. You can tell the staff really cares, even though they seemed a bit overwhelmed with the full foliage rush. That said, I think the food could be improved. The dishes sound more sophisticated than they actually are, and the prices don’t quite match the quality. My pasta (fusilli with mushrooms) was pretty basic, though the burger meat was very good. The outdoor area feels pretty standard, while the inside has an upscale vibe but confusing décor — the paintings don’t really fit the theme. The wine prices are also on the higher side, even compared to Manhattan. Overall, wonderful service and kind staff, but the menu and ambiance could use some adjustments to match what the place seems to aim for.

A charming Italian restaurant offering fresh, authentic Tuscan cuisine in a cozy, inviting atmosphere. The pastas are delicious and made with quality ingredients, and the outdoor garden seating adds to the experience. Friendly service and creative dishes make this a wonderful spot for lunch or dinner in town.

This restaurant was amazing! We walked in without a reservation on Saturday night and sat at the outside patio with our dog. They brought over water and treats for her immediately. Our waitress was super sweet. She was also making our cocktails and tailored them to how we liked. They have many specials as well so you’ll definitely find something good to eat. At the end of our meal, the manager Dan came over to chat with us and made sure we had a great meal. We told them it was our anniversary and they brought out dessert with a candle in it! Overall, awesome experience at Cathryn’s and highly recommend to anyone visiting cold spring!

Saturday evening, busy, reservation at 7 pm but we were seated after waiting15 min. Server took another 10 min to come. Bread hard and cold, over toasted, I was afraid for my teeth. We ordered Linguini Nero al' limone with shrimp. Those were the most unfresh and dry shrimp I ever ate. After eating the same dish in Aruba, that was superb, this one was a big disappointment. That was my experience at this restaurant.

Been coming here for most celebrations in my life and it's always a pleasure. The food is outstanding and a nice alternative compared to common italian restaurants. You wont find chicken parm here and it's a good thing. Step out of that comfort zone and try some new dishes and flavors! Staff is always so friendly and conversational. Looking forward to more anniversaries, birthdays, valentines and more at Cathryns