Cassie Cakes

Cassie made this AMAZING turtle pond cake for my son’s 9th birthday. He loves turtles, and wanted a cake with his pet turtle Mikey on it. I gave her some photos of Mikey, and she recreated her perfectly out of rice crispy treat and fondant. When my son saw this cake, he squealed and yelled it was the best cake ever. Thank you soooo much Cassie Cakes for making my kiddo’s birthday extra special! 💜💜💜

We’ve ordered our wedding cake, baby shower cake, and our son’s first birthday cake from Cassie Cakes over the years and each one has been stunning and delicious! They’re amazing at navigating food allergies and creating exactly what you have in mind. Incredible quality and service.

I ordered some custom cookies for my sister's baby shower which was themed "a baby is brewing." The cookies blew me away! They were adorable and everyone complimented her great they looked and tasted! I was very impressed with the simple ordering process and the way they took my idea and created exactly what I was going for! I definitely hope to use them again next time I need beautiful cookies.

Reply#1 10/30/2025 ------------------------------------------------ Let’s clarify a few things. The issue was not just a toothpick — there were sharp metal wires used inside the cake. That is a serious safety hazard, not something to downplay. As for pickup, I waited for your “ready for pickup” confirmation before coming in. There was nothing such. I had to call and confirm. Before placing order the responses were in time and spot on confirming and responding. The same shall be expected by a customer to know the cake is made and ready for delivery. The order included a $50 rush fee on top of a $250 cake (total $321). So no — this was not a favor or an exception. It was a paid service, and I expected professional handling. You mentioned that a team member stayed back after hours to delive

We’ve purchased many cakes over YEARS of business with cassie along with treats when we’ve stopped into the store and cookies for teachers at the start of school years. Cassie’s products are all absolutely delicious. She can do anything ! We’ve requested rainbow cakes for little girl birthdays, science themed cakes, unicorns, and many more and each time it’s come out adorable and delicious!