Casey's

Milton, WI · Pizza restaurant

Rating
4.1/5
★★★★☆ 4.1
Reviews
20
Rank in Milton
#5
of 17 restaurants
City Percentile
19%
rating percentile
Address
Casey's, 464 S John Paul Rd, Milton, WI 53563
Phone
(608) 868-4650
Website
www.caseys.com/general-store/wi-milton/464-s-john-paul-rd/1992?utm_medium=organic&utm_source=google&utm_campaign=DAC
Status
Closes soon · 10 PM · Opens 5 AM Sat

Casey's is a restaurant located in Milton, WI. It is one of 17 restaurants listed in Milton. Its 4.1-star rating is slightly below the Milton city average of 4.7 stars. It ranks #5 among Milton restaurants by combined rating and review volume. There are 3 photos associated with this location.

About Casey's

Your Milton Casey's at 464 S John Paul Rd has the best pizza delivery and pickup. Plus quality fuels, appetizers and drinks. Whatever you need, Casey's is here to help.

Hours

Friday5 AM–10 PM
Saturday5 AM–10 PM
Sunday5 AM–10 PM
Monday5 AM–10 PM
Tuesday5 AM–10 PM
Wednesday5 AM–10 PM
Thursday5 AM–10 PM

Customer Reviews

★★★★★ 5.0 Jessica O · Oct 2025

This Casey's is the go-to for pizza and top notch customer service! The PM crew are the best, and have always taken care of requests that i might have (marinara in cup) and even remember my usual purchases. Feels like family imo, and its getting harder to find that anywhere these days!

★☆☆☆☆ 1.0 Chris Perez · Dec 2025

I came in yesterday the guy at the register between 3-4pm was yelling and screaming at a lady in the office. This is not what I wanted to walk into. I was just coming to pick up my pizza. I think the guy should be fired

★☆☆☆☆ 1.0 Chelsea Stonewerth · Jan 2024

This is one of the worst Casey's I've ever been to! If you're a vegetarian, or have health restrictions, I'd avoid coming. The employee informed me they NEVER do non-meat pizzas for the warmer (grab-n-go option) even though they do half and half pizzas. If you place an order without meat it will still end up with meat on it, potentially extra as well. The layout is crammed and dingy without the same options as many other Casey's stores. I will give service 2 stars only because the one time I had Cam help me, he was amazing! He was super friendly and offered options if there was something unavailable. No one else that I've encountered here has given the customer service he has. It's not worth going back, Kwik Trip is right down the road in two different directions.

★☆☆☆☆ 1.0 D E · Jun 2019

Ordered 2 pizzas and cheese sticks. One pizza was fine as it wasn't complicated the second pizza apparently was too complicated as it was half was sausage and the other was Canadian bacon and green peppers and square cut. Well everything was delivered and the one pizza was fine the other everything was mixed as one whole pizza and regular cut. I called and they're no help offered to remake it and wait another hour. Just a bunch of idiot's. I will never step foot in that store and steer everyone I know away from there. I should of went to kwik trip.

★★★★★ 5.0 Caitlin Rote · Aug 2020

Caseys is always a good place to stop for gas and drinks/snacks. Most of the staff is incredible and not only can you order food at the kitchen there, you can also order ahead of time for pick-up/Delivery. Their pizza is awesome! They have other things in their kitchen as well, and you can usually find pretty good deals for kitchen food on the Caseys app. If you shop at Casey's, I'd HIGHLY recommend signing up for Casey's rewards. Points aquire quickly and you can use them for fuel discounts or to take a certain $ amount off your purchase. They also have deals with the rewards where if you buy 10 sodas, the next ones free, etc. Highly recommend over even Kwik Trip!

Accessibility & Amenities

✓ Curbside Pickup ✓ No Contact Delivery ✓ Delivery ✓ Onsite Services ✓ Takeout ✓ Dine In ✓ Fast Service ✓ Great Coffee ✓ Breakfast ✓ Lunch ✓ Wheelchair Accessible Entrance ✓ Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot ✓ Wheelchair Accessible Restroom ✓ Wheelchair Accessible Seating ✓ Alcohol ✓ Beer

Services

Pizza restaurantConvenience storeGas stationPizza delivery

Top Restaurants in Milton

NameRatingReviews
Good Works Brewing Company★★★★★ 4.820 reviews
Diegolin mexican restaurant★★★★★ 4.820 reviews
Sharla's Coffee Stop★★★★★ 4.720 reviews
Cafe 26★★★★★ 4.620 reviews
Subway★★★★☆ 4.020 reviews
The 59er Sip and Swing★★★★★ 5.02 reviews
Sharla's Bake Stop★★★★★ 5.00 reviews
Meyer Welding★★★★★ 5.00 reviews
Flour Fields Bakery★★★★★ 5.00 reviews
The Ice ShanTea★★★★★ 4.90 reviews

This listing is informational. Contact the business directly to verify credentials, services, and availability.