Casaletto Pizzeria

When it comes to pizza, NYC pizza is one of a kind. If you happen to be in this neighborhood then you must grab a pie or two. Let’s not forget the Jamaican beef patty and the staff definitely made you feel welcomed and oh thank you for the chicken Parmesan sample that was quite tasty. I enjoyed my Hawaiian pineapple pizza too.

We stopped in here Saturday night during the street fair for Halloween. They were one of the few businesses nice enough to let people use the bathroom even if they didn’t buy anything. The staff were friendly and efficient. Pizza was good. I just got a plain slice. Sadly they brought out the white pizza as I was leaving. I would definitely come back the next time I’m in Sleepy Hollow.

What a fantastic experience at Casaletto Pizzeria! We tried the "Headless Horseman" pizza and it was absolutely delicious—every bite was a flavor explosion. Beyond the incredible food, the service was outstanding. Our order came out quickly, and the staff was incredibly friendly and attentive. The place itself was clean with clean restrooms, which is always a huge plus. Best of all, the prices were very reasonable for the quality and experience you get. It's a rare find to have such great food and service that's also easy on the wallet. Casaletto Pizzeria is a must-visit spot, and we'll definitely be back for more!

My go-to take-out pizza! Delicious thin dough/crust which holds up to a large amount of generous toppings no matter which you choose. Flavorful sauce. Plentiful real slices of fresh onion, peppers, or chunks of tomatoes and pepperoni. I first tasted this pizza on an order from the Too Good to Go app. So glad I did! At busy times in the evening, it can take a couple of extra minutes to park in a public lot as street parking is popular.

The best New York Style Pizza ever, perfect timing on big orders where most pizzerias seem to fail these guys are always on point.