Casa Stellina Ristorante

I had my bridal shower here a few weeks ago and it was amazing! Mike, the manager, was so helpful and made sure everything went perfectly; and the staff were all super nice and attentive.They had a great menu of things to choose from that were served family style for my guests, and everyone kept raving about how good the food was, especially their chicken parm. I had 45 guests and had my shower in the main dining room that can hold up to 60, but they also have a gorgeous back room as well for smaller groups!! Would highly recommend for a rehearsal dinner or baby/bridal shower!

We went to Casa Stellina for my daughter's birthday. We were greeted warmly by the hostess and she asked whose birthday it was based on our Open Table reservation. She wished my daughter a happy birthday. The service was good and the staff checked on us to see if everything was OK. My daughter didn't care for one dish and the waiter took it off the bill, no questions asked. We ordered one dessert to share and I was surprised that it didn't have a candle. When the check arrived, I asked the waiter if they normally provide a birthday candle. He said to wait a few minutes, then came back with 2 complimentary desserts with a candle. This is a classy restaurant and our waiter Marlon was great.

The service he was amazing the host Michael was hands down the best part of the experience..... everyone that worked here was the best and attentive The food was to die for I ordered the octopus and meatballs which was very flavorful and the porterhouse steak was one of the best I have ever tasted The atmosphere was amazing I highly recommend to go eat here you will not be disappointed

This is a great new addition to Farmingdale. My friend and I decided to have dinner here because the decor was so classy and chic. What we didn't expect was how wonderful the service would be too! Our waiter did an excellent job of checking on us frequently and giving great recommendations. As other reviews have mentioned, the food and wine were great and the portions were large. Seriously, the bread, the pasta, and the dessert were to die for. I will definitely be returning for a fancy date night!

I recently hosted my birthday party at Casa Stellina with a group of 30 guests, and it was an incredible experience from start to finish. The manager, Mike, was so helpful throughout the planning process and went above and beyond—even surprising me with a birthday cake! The food was absolutely amazing, and the drinks were delicious. Our servers, Siobhan and Nick, provided outstanding service—attentive, friendly, and efficient. The music and overall atmosphere were vibrant, fun, and perfect for a celebration. I highly recommend Casa Stellina for any special occasion or just a great night out. I’ll definitely be back!