Carmine & Ray's Pizza

The pizza is delicious if you’re picking up a slice to go, eating in restaurant or ordering for delivery. The new owner is so kind, normal, down to earth. I called today on a busy Friday night during Lent and asked for the pizza to be extra hot and he made it happen which I truly appreciate. The crust is thin and crispy, perfect ratio of sauce to cheese. Carmine and Rays is my go to in Closter and surrounding areas if you want a nice slice.

Really the best pizza in the Closter and the surrounding areas by a long shot!! The flavor, especially the marinara sauce, is fantastic! Definitely recommend.

Spectacular pizza! We just moved to Cresskill and we’ve been looking for a go-to. It’s Carmine and Ray’s. The slices are the perfect thinness, very crispy. The toppings they use are high quality. The staff are so friendly. Delivery came quick. Couldn’t recommend them more.

This is my spot. The pizza is great. Big fan of their sauce over other places in the area. Chris and Roland are always a blast to talk to and they remember the patrons. I usually get delivery, but stop in to BS with them. Thanks guys.

We spent a week in the New York area, and we loved this place so much that we went back a second time. They had really good pizza and garlic knots, and the Stromboli was out of this world. I highly recommend Carmine & Rays.