Carlo's

Classic Yonkers staple of Italian American food. Reservations strongly recommended for dinner, as we went for a 645p reservation and the place was packed. Food was great, only problem was the wait for the food to come out. 1/2 off wine on tuesdays & they also have a pizza spot at the bottom of the building. Would recommend

I've had take out before when I visit my uncle in Yonkers. Finally had a sit down experience on one of the busiest nights of the year NEW YEARS EVE. Not only was the food amazing and the service phenomenal you can feed a family of 3 with 1 dish (with chicken dishes under $30). This place is top notch to say the least.

A longtime local favorite that truly feels like home. I used to attend RHS in the ’90s, back when Pete Sr. was running the show. Not many people could get Pete to crack a joke, but I was lucky enough to be one of his favorites—and I wore that badge of honor proudly. He would be so proud to see how Carlo’s is still going strong today, expanding in ways this community truly couldn’t live without. The food is always on point. Some of my personal favorites include the fried burrata over pesto, chicken scarpariello, Valdostana, arugula salad, cutlets, and their espresso martinis—just to name a few. Carlo’s isn’t just a restaurant; it’s a piece of local history done right.

The Yonkers Nostalgia mandated a 5 star rating. Is it perfect, no. Is it delicious, savory, generously portioned Italian food? Absolutely. Growing up cruising central ave this was a great spot for pizza downstairs in their lower level, or a Yonkers staple such as a chicken parm "wedge" upstairs. Ive gone back a several times over the past few years. Their red sauce is still of high quality and i was very satisfied with the meal overall. Great stop off heading home after a Yankee game, just minutes from the Sprain Pkwy, or any trip to the city. Nice to support businesses that have been around so long as well. Very nostalgic dining experience!

Food is good, atmosphere is nice. Place gets packed! Definitely reserve a table if you can. Chicken parm was delicious and penne with vodka sauce was good but darker than I'm used to and they left out bacon bits in it. That garden salad with their homemade dressing 😍 They also accommodate big parties of 20+