Carlo's Gourmet Pizzeria, Restaurant & Caterers

I wouldn't say this is your typical NJ Pizza Joint. It actually has a nice seating area when you go around the wall to your left. No, it would handle large groups. But. the space it neat and decorated nicely. It's not benches and tables The guy at the counter was very friendly. Took our orders right away and brought the food to our table. The pizza was good. It wasn't floppy. The deep dish pepperoni was a bit burnt, but was still flavorful. Carlo's Gourmet Pizza is worth checking out.

Ordered two pizzas, one gluten-free and one regular marg — but received two gluten-free. We called and they offered to send the regular marg, which we appreciated. Just to clarify, they only sent one replacement. The other pizza was part of our original order that we paid for. It wasn’t an extra. Mistakes happen and we weren’t upset about that. The issue was that the replacement took over 55 minutes to arrive and was genuinely cold when it got here (we live nearby, so this was surprising). When we called just to give feedback, a staff member was rude and told us they had already sent three pizzas, which completely missed the point. We weren’t asking for a refund or anything, just trying to let them know what happened. Genuinely disappointing experience from Carlo’s since we usually enjo

Been living in town for over 10yrs and finally found this spot. The pizza is awesome, good hold, nice crust, no flop, and sauce is nice n lil sweet. From plain slice to pepperoni to grandma to my fav of chix bacon ranch. The garlic knot chicken parm sandwich was good but was very doughy (obviously). Chicken parm was decent and could use some more seasoning. All in all, great neighborhood pizza spot.

We hosted my daughter's birthday party here on 3/8/25. The adorable party room blew us away. The room was set up when we walked in and the balloons arrived early and were already placed in the right spots. The room is adorable and the overall party experience is even better! Laurie was the best host. Parties can fit up to 50 people, 20 kids making pizza. Each kid gets a pizza board, sauce, and cheese to make their pie! It was the best experience and highly recommend it. Already planning our next party!

The riceball special was full of salt. They put a little bit of ricotta and mos cheese on it. The overall taste was awful and the presentation the same. The pizza was just okay. I won't be going back. There are too many pizza places to visit where you can get good food.