Capone's Pizza

Excellent pizza. Perfect dough with good fermentation and chew. You can tell they take pride in the quality of ingredients. Highly recommend

Im working out of town so I decided to order in at the motel. I am tired of sub par over priced food. I should have just stuck with a known chain pizza restaurant. My salad was so hot and wilted I threw that right in the trash. They got the flavor of my wings wrong but I still ate them as I was hungry from working all day. And the pizza wells ive had wat better frozen. So for $60 for one person to eat crap food sucks. I would waste my money or time with this place.

Was staying in West Jefferson with family. Daughter and son-in-law said Capone’s was their favorite pizza place. They ordered take out and then drove from West Jefferson to Boone to pick it up, approximately 50 mile round trip. When he returned to the cabin and opened the pizza box we were shocked. We had an extra large burnt pizza. The crust was black and pepperoni was crispy. None of the other toppings were recognizable. We each ate a small slice and had to throw away the rest of the pizza. They said this was the last time they would order from Capone’s. When I go with them and want pizza I’ll go to Little Caesars which is five minutes from their cabin, not 1 hour.

The food LOOKED decent, as my photos show, but we were highly disappointed. We ordered the "garlic" knots which ended up being just underbaked dough with some kind of watery butter poured over them. No garlic flavor. Also ordered a pepperoni calzone and manicotti. The cheese in both was very chewy mozerella, likely frozen, and the pasta was undercooked. There was almost no flavor to anything. The marinara dipping sauce was decent, but for an Italian place, it was an insult to Italian cuisine. Their whole service model was unusual, and even though our meal was comped by the manager, she showed zero interest in why we were not happy with our meal. That proved to me that this place has no interest in improving or at least proving anything more than tasteless, cheap food for people with low ex

They made us "a pizza we couldn't refuse". It was a bit pricey, but nothing that the G-men could get us for evasion. The setup of ordering at the counter and no waiters was fine with us; no rush, no hassles. Note: for those complaining about this gimmick, if you need something, ASK AT THE COUNTER!