Bruster's Real Ice Cream

Locals' favorite ice cream 🍦 is made on-site using traditional methods with fresh cream from its own dairy farm in Titusville, PA, to each store where it's then crafted into small-batch. It is fresh, thick, and creamy, served daily in a variety of regular and seasonal flavors.

Staff is very helpful, especially Blake. Offered to make my grandmother coconut ice cream because it's her favorite, and they can! Just have to place the order a few days in advance. Wonderful!! Great flavored creamy ice cream...blows Lusby Baskin Robbins out of the water!

Ima be honest. I do love the ice cream and the people because I always get my order right and they are patient. the only problem is I often times find hair in my dessert. Last night I was coming home from gym and treated myself well when I got home I had a long strand of hair around the rims of the snickers blast and I could have called but it was gettn late. I just think it really needs to be aware and peeps needa keep their hair covered because it’s happened to my Ma plenty of times which is why she don’t come here anymore and I don’t blame her but it’s icky to eat and know sum shouldn’t be in it

Drive thru was on the longer side today but they were still really fast and attentive to our large order. Wish they didn’t run out of the cheesecake oreo but what I got was still good.

The ice cream is very tasty to start. My issue is when I took my two daughters there we ordered three two scoop waffle cones and they charged me $44. I looked at the menus and the listed price was $6.99 per two scoop waffle cone. I asked the worker about the price and she told me that the prices changed but the menus were never updated (that’s illegal). Your ice cream is good but at that price I’ll just go to the store and buy equally good for a fraction of the price.