Brother's Pizzeria

I confess. I can't tell if I'm more addicted to the pizza, or to Riley! No, really. I didn't care for squares. However, I'd promised myself I'd try all the pizza places on SI that people tout. And, I'd tried the rest...And, I liked or loved the rest... But, the first night I tried Brothers, it begat two more nights in the same weekend. It's become my naughty go-to, and the place I often grab pizzas to bring with me to friends, afar. I really try to restrain myself and it doesn't often work. I'm so in love that when I go in, I just get whatever's still warm. I love it all: plain sicilian, upside down, gramma, or even a plain slice! The staff is RIDICULOUS! They are not only crazy friendly, they're ON IT. I have a huge soft spot for my three guys--Riley, Will and VG--but you cannot go wrong

I love their pizza, but today 12/20 my pie was a little burnt

I think it just might be me. This place was crowded (with what seemed like a lot of regular customers), and it was too busy to answer phone, and there’s a bunch of testimonials that swear by the pizza here. For me, meh. I ordered two grandma squares and nothing about them was memorable. I did detect the freshness of the tomato sauce, but I have no other praise to offer other than that. Price of $7 was fair. Very spacious dining area. I sat at a table underneath a photo of The Sopranos cast. I didn’t dislike my pizza, but it didn’t impress me either. I wouldn’t go out of my way to come here again, but I do encourage anyone who’s never been here to give it a try and judge for themselves. Because it could just be me.

Delicious! The pepperoni pinwheels were the best thing I’ve ever eaten! The staff were also super friendly and we loved everything we ate! Best pizza place in the city! (Do be mindful, it is cash only!)

OK Tough Guy – Stop claiming to be from New York City. Everyone knows you’re from Milford, Pennsylvania or Fishkill, New York – Please spare us the lies and stolen valor. Bronx born, Long Island raised, Toured the Means Streets of Every Borough in this City – Battling the Demons in countless Emergency Rooms across the great city of New York – And, yes – I lived in Queens throughout my tenure which traumatized me. No Psychiatrist could calm be down; The only thing I could find to relax me is a good slice and an ice cold Mexican Coca Cola; - I’ve had them all, across Queens, Manhattan, Brooklyn, the Bronx and in the current decade – G-d has brought me to Staten Island. If you are still reading this, I guess you have figured it out, sizzle chest, this Fat Hebrew boy knows what he’s talking ab