Brother's Pizza

Brother’s Pizza is hands-down our favorite place in Newville. The customer service is always great, and the pizza never disappoints. We’ve made it our go-to for family nights, and on lazy days, we love that they deliver right to Newville—super convenient. They even have gambling machines if you’re feeling lucky while waiting for your food. Great spot all around!

I hate leaving reviews. This pizza is not even edible. No one could eat this and not get sick. You can’t even pick up a slice without the toppings sliding off and just having pure mush dough. I’m not from this area and just moved here so maybe I’m just not used to how the pizza is in this state.

Ordered late tonight . Had to wait for my cheese pizza and salad. Good food is always worth the wait. Fantastic taste and distribution of ingredients on my salad. Not getting a forklift full of lettuce. 👌

Listen, I take my pizza seriously. I don’t want a slice that looks like it just gave up on life. I don’t want a slice that flops over like a wet towel the second gravity gets involved. That is sad pizza. That is pizza that needs therapy. Brothers Pizza? They understand structural integrity. The pizza here stands tall and proud. It respects you. It holds its own weight. It’s crispy, it’s cheesy, and it doesn’t suffer from "Performance Anxiety Flop" like certain other establishments roughly one block away (I won't name names, but we all know who makes the cardboard frisbees of sadness). And the Cheese Steak Sub? Put it in the Louvre. It is a work of art. It’s amazing. It’s the kind of sub that makes you want to write poetry, or at least text your mom about how good your lunch is. Do yours

Place was okay, service was ok. Store cases of drinks in front of the bathroom door that you have to maneuver the door just to get in and out of the bathroom. Fountain drink machine out of service. Ground beef topping for pizza was more like meatballs that looked like sausage.