Brother's Pizza Greencastle

Casual restaurant next door to the Holiday Inn. Although known for their pizza, I opted for the manicotti. It came with salad and bread. No beer or wine so I opted for the non-alcoholic birch beer which was very tasty. Aleia <sp>was my server and she was friendly and very sweet.

Absolutely fantastic experience at Brother's Pizza in Greencastle! We tried the Eggplant Parmesan, Cheesesteak, and wings — and every bite was excellent. The Eggplant Parmesan was perfectly cooked with a rich, flavorful sauce, the Cheesesteak was packed with tender meat and melty cheese, and the wings were crispy, juicy, and full of flavor. What made our visit even better was our server, Lexi. She was spot on the entire time — friendly, attentive, and an absolute joy to work with. She made us feel welcome and taken care of from start to finish. Highly recommend this spot for delicious food and top-notch service. We’ll definitely be back!

Ive honestly been meaning to leave a review for a while now. Talk about a good local pizza spot. Food is great. Love the pizza/subs. Plenty of options to choose from. Haven't had a bad meal from here. Prices are great.Don't let it being connected to the Holiday Inn deceive you. Also, they deliver for a fantastic price compared to doordash and uber eats and the food is always piping hot and the delivery drivers are extremely friendly and professional. I have zero complaints. I eat here once a week at least.

I take my family once or twice a month. Great staff. The food is always consistent and delicious. The homemade chips are addictive. Always friendly and professional staff. My only complaint would be from my daughter who misses the claw machine and checks every time hoping it's back.

Easy one minute off of I-81, quick sit down meal. Friendly service and good food. Sirloin steak salad with avocado, blue cheese and a side of fries. The onion rings were cooked perfectly and the dipping sauce yummy ! The family loved the subs and said the bread was really good. We will be back.